Mir Taqi Mir

সুবাতাস বলে যাও, কিছুই কি যায় আসে

বসন্ত এসেছে বলে আজ

যখন রিক্ত আমি, হারিয়েছি সবই

আমার কুলায় ও উদ্যান?

-         মীর তাকি মীর

The Pandemic and We

According to worldometer.info/coronavirus, the cumulative figures for the COVID-19 pandemic for the US, the UK, and India yesterday (04 May 2019) were:

USA – 1,212,835 cases; 69,921 deaths

UK – 190,584 cases; 28,734 deaths

India – 46,476 cases; 1,571 deaths

Compared to the US and the UK, the governments of which botched up their initial response to the pandemic and allowed the disease to spread freely, India has fared way better, particularly if you consider that we have a much larger population and much poorer healthcare facilities. However, before we hurt ourselves patting our own backs, let’s also contrast ourselves with two comparable countries in terms of geography, population density, and infrastructure.

Pakistan – 20,941 cases; 476 deaths

Bangladesh – 10,143 cases; 182 deaths

And let’s not even try to compare ourselves with those that have managed the pandemic effectively. Vietnam which has a population of 95 million (9.5 crores) has reported 271 cases and ZERO deaths. Wow! (New Zealand has been much touted by the media, but it has a population under five million (50 lakhs) hardly comparable to India)

I wouldn’t hazard a guess why the figures are far lower in resource-starved South Asia compared to many European countries and the US. However, as far as our country is concerned, let’s not jump to congratulate the government in New Delhi because we haven’t seen any transparent message from them on what percentage of population we’re testing to identify the cases early, how many new hospital beds we have created, how many PPE kits have been given to our doctors and other health workers, or even how many additional ventilators have been procured. Leaders of civilised countries reel out these figures, while our leaders are silent on them but prefer to shower us with rose petals from helicopters.

This government loves self-publicity and the absence of full-page adverts in newspapers tells us they have very little to say.

Also, healthcare is a state subject and we have seen responses from state governments that range from brilliant to abysmal. Clearly, Kerala has done brilliantly, but there have been miracles elsewhere too, like in Chhattisgarh (58 cases, no death), Asom (43 cases, 1 death), and Odisha (170 cases, 1 death).

At the other end of the spectrum is West Bengal, which seems to be spending more energy and time fudging coronavirus-related statistics than fighting the pandemic. Everyone I speak with in Kolkata seems mortified. They know if they contract the disease, they will have to deal with an insane healthcare bureaucracy and will have little chance.

But as Indians, let’s hope the pandemic won’t become a mass-killer like it has been in the US, UK, Spain, Italy, and France.

Experience has taught us to be less fanciful with hopes.

05 May 2020

The Cuckoo’s Nest

Malayalam writer Sethu began his literary journey in the 1960s and over time, became a leading author in his language. The Cuckoo’s Nest is not a translation of one of his Malayalam works; it’s the first novel Sethu has written in English. It was an excellent idea for him to tell the story in a language that is followed by a significant section of the educated Indian middleclass. The Cuckoo’s Nest makes us reflect on some of the dreadful realities of our time in the context of the country as a whole.

In a short, 260-page novel, can anyone cover a range of truths from the bottomless misogyny that cuts across geography and cultures of India, to the deep hatred of the upper-caste Hindu towards the the children of lesser gods, to the “othering” of a part of our own people for pitiless political gains and the eager collaboration of a part of the Hindu religious establishment in the project, to the hypocrisy of the Catholic Church, and more importantly, to an undercurrent of love and tolerance of a people which are much older than the Western concept of liberal humanism, and which has held together a civilisation for five thousand years? Can you think of a novel that connects a Khap Panchayets of Haryana to an exploitative convent in Tamilnadu and yet manages to convey a message not of despair but of resounding hope? I wouldn’t have, unless I had read this novel.

The central character of The Cuckoo’s Nest is a former holy sister who has renounced her role in a convent, but not her faith in Jesus. Sister Agatha has left her convent and set up – with the help of some other noble souls in a small town in Tamilnadu – a home for young women who the society throws out for one reason or another. Her shelter becomes a microcosm of those margins of the Indian society where lots of unfortunate Indian women struggle before falling off the cliff. Agatha’s aim is to offer them a nest until they are ready to fly away. In the context of her nest, she is religion-neutral and doesn’t preach. Rather, she forbids religion there, except within the personal space of each occupant.

Agatha doesn’t tread the hackneyed path of tailoring classes or formal “education”. She doesn’t even hand-hold the hopeless girls. She just encourages them to find their own path to an honourable life. Some of them succeed, some don’t.

But the story of every one of the unfortunate girls makes compelling reading. While offering a glimpse into a largely unknown world, Sethu weaves their yarns with the refined skill of a master craftsman, which makes the book easy reading, despite its somewhat heavy contents. However, I wish he had the support of a more ruthless editor and the book was free from the rather numerous linguistic glitches and typos.

[The Cuckoo's Nest, Sethu, Niyogi Books, New Delhi, 2019]

22 April 2020

A fascist shows his fangs

Prannoy Roy recently said if the Indian media is asked to bend, they crawl.

Thanks to the crawlers, we find it difficult to access credible news. The mainstream newspapers, barring exceptions, publish government press releases most of the time. The TV channels are mostly unwatchable. Let me give you two examples.

The prime minister has set up a private trust to collect donations to deal with the COVID-19 pandemic, putting aside the PM's National Relief Fund which has been in existence since 1948. The new fund has been self-aggrandisingly named PM-CARES Fund. The Wikipedia says: “No one knows when it was registered, under which act, and why it [does] not contain any members of civil society or opposition as part of the trust.” (Accessed on 13/04/2030). Also, the trust isn’t covered under the RTI Act. So, the public has no way to find out how the amounts received will be spent. What level of arrogance can make the PM set up an opaque private fund in the time of the gravest crisis since independence, when he should act openly and transparently?

Secondly, India’s Corona virus cases are relatively small and we are happy about it. Let’s take a step back and check how many people India have been tested and compare it with a few other countries. According to a report published in the Business Standard on 9 April 2020, three countries had tested the following numbers till then FOR EVERY MILLION (1,000,000) PEOPLE:

Spain:                  18,300

South Korea:              60

India:                            4

  

A lot of experts believe India’s low level of testing is reflected in the relatively fewer cases, which is also a common-sense argument. If we may go back to the figures, it would be pointless to compare India with European nations, but for a country the leadership of which sells the fake dream of becoming a “Vishwa Guru”, can we not ask why India tested 1/15th of what South Korea, another emerging economy, did?

In a true democracy, the media will tear the government apart over the two issues I have flagged. But have you seen many discussions on them in the mainstream media, barring exceptions?

Fortunately, we have some new web-based news portals which offer us true news. They are run mostly by crowd-funding. The finest examples are THE WIRE and THE SCROLL. We should also mention Pratik Sinha’s Altnews.in, which has been doing a fantastic work. (If you haven’t, please do visit the website and check how much fake news is peddled by different sides of the political divide.)

The fascist powers that rule us cannot be happy with these upstart news portals which have captured the imagination of a lot of Indians, particularly the young. And they are not sitting idle.  

Recently, the UP government has filed criminal cases against Siddharth Varadarajan, Founding Editor of the Wire. The UP government accuses the Wire of “causing panic when it reported that UP chief minister Yogi Adityanath attended a religious event on March 25 at Ayodhya on the occasion of Ram Navmi”, long after a nation-wide lockdown was in place.

The Wire argues that the UP CM’s presence was an undisputable, recorded fact. However, in the article the Wire had “wrongly attributed a statement made by Acharya Paramhans to the chief minister, which was not only retracted but a corrigendum issued as well.”

In a statement made on 11 April 2020, 215 journalists have described the above event and issued a statement saying:

“Rather than let the matter end there, a FIR was filed in Faizabad district. On April 10, a team of the UP police descended at Siddharth Varadarajan’s residence to serve him a notice for appearing on April 14, irrespective of the fact that a nationwide lockdown was in force. … The state has an extra responsibility to exercise restraint on use of its powers when citizens are restricted in exercising many of their usual democratic rights. Freedom of the press is doubly important in such a context as people cannot make news themselves, but independent media is the most important medium of expressing their concerns. We demand that such politically motivated harassment of media persons should stop immediately.”

The New York Times tagline says, “Democracy dies in darkness.”

And what can be a quicker way to ensure darkness than to silence journalists by brute force or threats?

Monday, 13 April 2020